Luis Miguel Romero Rodríguez
  • Home
  • Bio
  • Publications
  • Media
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Español
  • Menu Menu

Publications +

Learning Leaders: Teachers or Youtubers?

Participatory Culture and STEM Competencies in Italian Secondary School Students

Learning Leaders in STEM: Teachers or YouTubers? Insights from Italian Secondary Education

What is this article about?

This article explains how Italian secondary students perceive and use YouTube and educational influencers as learning tools, especially for mathematical STEM competencies. Gil-Quintana, Malvasi, Castillo-Abdul, and Romero-Rodríguez surveyed 4,845 Italian adolescents and analyzed the content and impact of Elia Bombardelli, a popular math youtuber. They compared these findings with insights from teachers through interviews.


Why is it important?

This research reveals a significant generational shift in educational leadership: while students value teachers for in-person learning, they rate YouTubers higher as digital learning figures, especially when facing difficulty in subjects like math. The study offers practical and ethical implications for digital education, influencer culture, and participatory learning.


Key Findings

1. YouTube is the top STEM learning tool

  • 80% of students use YouTube to learn math at home

  • YouTube surpasses apps like Photomath, Geogebra, or textbooks

  • 35% use it in class; only 22% of teachers include it in lessons

2. Adolescents trust youtubers over teachers

  • Youtubers scored 8.32/10 vs. teachers’ 7.84/10

  • Influencers are seen as more enthusiastic and clearer, though less variable in content

3. The most-followed youtuber is Elia Bombardelli

  • 49% of students recognize him as their preferred math youtuber

  • Strong engagement: 299,000 subscribers, 30k views/video, 10% engagement rate

4. Preference varies by region and school type

  • Students in Sardinia prefer youtubers to teachers

  • Technical school students use YouTube more than those in professional institutes

5. High number of followers correlates with low math performance

  • Adolescents with 5,000+ followers perform worse in math

  • Those active in participatory culture often face challenges balancing screen time and academics


Methodology

  • Mixed methods: quantitative surveys + qualitative interviews

  • Tools: Google Forms, SPSS, Atlas.ti, Influencity

  • Participants: 4,845 students (aged 13–22), 12 math teachers, analysis of 15 YouTube videos


FAQs

Q: Do Italian students prefer youtubers over teachers?
A: They rate youtubers higher but still prefer teachers for direct interaction and help.

Q: Is YouTube effective for math learning?
A: Yes. It’s widely used and considered helpful across gender, age, and geographic areas.

Q: Who is Elia Bombardelli?
A: Italy’s most-followed math youtuber, known for clear explanations and accessible videos.

Q: Should teachers worry?
A: No. Teachers remain vital but should adapt digital strategies and learn from influencer engagement models.

Gil-Quintana, J., Malvasi, V., Castillo-Abdul, B., & Romero-Rodríguez, L. M. (2020). Learning Leaders: Teachers or Youtubers? Participatory Culture and STEM Competencies in Italian Secondary School Students. Sustainability, 12(18), 7466. http:/dx.doi.org/10.3390/su12187466

DOWNLOAD

Other Publications

Social Media and Seniors: Trends in Lifelong Media Education
  • Articles
  • Publications

Social Media and Seniors: Trends in Lifelong Media Education

26 June, 2025
This article presents a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of 2,695 publications from 1995 to 2023 on the use of social media...
Read More
Misleading YouTube Info on Back Pain: Study Warns Users
  • Articles
  • Publications

Misleading YouTube Info on Back Pain: Study Warns Users

17 June, 2025
This article explains the results of a recent study on Spanish-language YouTube videos about lower back pain. The research, published...
Read More
Museum Communication: Strategies and Audiences
  • Articles
  • Publications

Museum Communication: Strategies and Audiences

21 May, 2025
This study explores how museums in Spain develop and implement communication strategies to connect with their audiences, promote cultural participation,...
Read More
Happiness Management in Internal Communication
  • Articles
  • Publications

Happiness Management in Internal Communication

21 May, 2025
Happiness Management is a human-centered approach to corporate communication, focusing on employee well-being, emotional experience, and workplace satisfaction. This study...
Read More
AI and Big Data in Journalism Education: Spain’s Gap
  • Articles
  • Publications

AI and Big Data in Journalism Education: Spain’s Gap

21 May, 2025
This study evaluates how journalism education in Spain incorporates artificial intelligence (AI) and big data into university curricula. These emerging...
Read More
Hospital Website Quality: New Model for Spanish Health Centers
  • Articles
  • Publications

Hospital Website Quality: New Model for Spanish Health Centers

21 May, 2025
The Hospital Web Quality Multicriteria Analysis Model (HWQ) is a validated tool to evaluate the digital presence of hospitals. It...
Read More
Eco-Influencers on Instagram: Content or Fandom?
  • Articles
  • Publications

Eco-Influencers on Instagram: Content or Fandom?

21 May, 2025
Eco-influencers are social media personalities who promote sustainable lifestyles, often blending activism with product advertising. On Instagram, they have emerged...
Read More
YouTube and Low Back Pain: Education or Misinformation?
  • Articles
  • Publications

YouTube and Low Back Pain: Education or Misinformation?

21 May, 2025
Low back pain (LBP) is a leading cause of disability worldwide. Many patients now turn to YouTube for information, influenced...
Read More
Streaming, Censorship, and Gen Z: Postcensorship Insights
  • Articles
  • Publications

Streaming, Censorship, and Gen Z: Postcensorship Insights

21 May, 2025
Postcensorship refers to a modern form of censorship where content creators preemptively alter or suppress material to avoid social backlash....
Read More
Fact-Checking and Fake News Research Trends
  • Articles
  • Publications

Fact-Checking and Fake News Research Trends

19 May, 2025
This article explains** the evolution of fact-checking and fake news research within the social sciences between 2014 and 2022. The...
Read More

©️ Copyright Luis M. Romero-Rodríguez | All Rights Reserved   |   Site Developed by AIMRTECHNOLOGY

Scroll to top
Gestionar el consentimiento de las cookies
Para ofrecer las mejores experiencias, utilizamos tecnologías como las cookies para almacenar y/o acceder a la información del dispositivo. El consentimiento de estas tecnologías nos permitirá procesar datos como el comportamiento de navegación o las identificaciones únicas en este sitio. No consentir o retirar el consentimiento, puede afectar negativamente a ciertas características y funciones.
Funcional Always active
El almacenamiento o acceso técnico es estrictamente necesario para el propósito legítimo de permitir el uso de un servicio específico explícitamente solicitado por el abonado o usuario, o con el único propósito de llevar a cabo la transmisión de una comunicación a través de una red de comunicaciones electrónicas.
Preferencias
El almacenamiento o acceso técnico es necesario para la finalidad legítima de almacenar preferencias no solicitadas por el abonado o usuario.
Estadísticas
El almacenamiento o acceso técnico que es utilizado exclusivamente con fines estadísticos. El almacenamiento o acceso técnico que se utiliza exclusivamente con fines estadísticos anónimos. Sin un requerimiento, el cumplimiento voluntario por parte de tu proveedor de servicios de Internet, o los registros adicionales de un tercero, la información almacenada o recuperada sólo para este propósito no se puede utilizar para identificarte.
Marketing
El almacenamiento o acceso técnico es necesario para crear perfiles de usuario para enviar publicidad, o para rastrear al usuario en una web o en varias web con fines de marketing similares.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Ver preferencias
{title} {title} {title}